Israel is in the midst of an election cycle, and beneath the noise, the real question is not left versus right but who decides – who sets policy, and can the public replace those who do at the ballot box. Several weeks ago, Makor Rishon published our “Covenant for the State” – the three pillars that should be endorsed by any political party that sees itself as Zionist and liberal (in the positive sense of the word): national sovereignty, individual liberty, and rule of the people and its representatives.
To begin with the first pillar, sovereignty. Israel is the nation-state of the Jewish people, and it is committed to individual rights and equality before the law for all of its citizens. There is no contradiction between the two – national self-determination for the Jewish people, and individual rights for all citizens. Israel must defend itself: freedom of action on the security front, a refusal to capitulate to political blackmail and terrorism, and the resolute enforcement of law against organized crime. Sovereignty also means equally applying the rule of law in every residential area, and preventing foreign government interference in domestic affairs – including all decisions on the country’s future, which belong exclusively to its elected institutions. The connection to the Jewish people obligates the state to encourage aliya, strengthen relations with the Jewish Diaspora and remove bureaucratic barriers that delay the integration of olim – while at the same time preventing the illegal settlement of labor migrants, and determining on its own who can enter its borders.
The second pillar is individual liberty, primarily in education and the economy. The high cost of living is the result of centralization, dense regulation and import barriers. The solution is simple to formulate and hard to carry out: ease the tax burden, dismantle monopolies and cartels, free up land, and open the market to competition. Uphold freedom of association and freedom of occupation while opposing enforced membership in workers’ or employers’ organizations; uphold the right to strike while restricting strikes in vital services industries and banning political strikes that harm the uninvolved public. The same logic applies to education: School principals should be authorized to recruit their teachers; parents should be free to choose their children’s schools; and budgets should be allocated on a per-student basis – all these will create incentives for excellence that a centralized system cannot achieve.
The third pillar lies at the heart of democracy: who decides. The determination of public policy and questions of value are the prerogative of elected representatives whom voters can replace at the ballot box – not bureaucrats or judges. The Knesset, alongside the ability of voters to influence the selection of their representatives, must be strengthened. The enactment of Basic Laws must be anchored, and judges should be appointed by elected representatives of the public. In tandem, the judiciary must be strengthened specifically in its primary role: protecting individual rights from being violated by the state, without undermining the authority of the Knesset and government to set policy. Separating the prosecutorial power from the Attorney General position, alongside setting term limits for senior positions, will ensure that the professional civil service remains subordinate to whomever the public voted for. A lean government – reduced in size and scope – will also shorten the distance between citizens and decision-makers on various issues, thus promoting efficiency, liberty and good governance.
The “Covenant for the State” does not offer magical solutions. Rather, it points to a direction that should be endorsed by any Zionist and liberal political party: less centralization, more choice, and elected rule that is as close to the citizens as possible.
(First appeared in Hebrew in a special elections edition by Makor Rishon)